GOTHAM LASIK

05/06/2008 Posted by wendyholder

Dr. Bonnani just did my LASIK eye surgery 2 weeks ago and I can't say enough good things about Gotham Lasik and how well I was treated there. I was very skeptical going in with all the various news coverage about Lasik and is everybody a good candidate or not. Dr. Bonnani explained to me after the free consultation that I was an excellent candidate and he would never perform a lasik surgery on anyone who he thought wouldn't be and there have been actually hundreds of patients he has personally turned down through his many years of practice. He explained that is the whole reason there is any news at all on the topic of Lasik lately. Unfortunately he said there are practitioners out there who will operate on anybody just to make a quick buck and these people hurt the reputation of the whole industry. I love the freedom of no more contacts and the hassle of cleaning them, buying them, forgetting about them etc... My only regret is that I didn't do it sooner, like 5 yrs. ago sooner! I only went to 2 different places before I made my decision to go with Dr. Bonnani & Gotham Lasik. The other place was incredibly cheap only a couple of hundred of $ per eye. But then I read that you would be insane to actually get that proceedure if you valued your vision. I think the place offered the same real lasik like Gotham Lasik does but I was already turned off to them. I felt like it was some cheap scam to get you in there and then try to sell you on the more expensive, but all along better choice for eye surgery for your vision. Anyway, I am so happy I choose Gotham Lasik. Thank you Dr. Bonnani. You rock!

Pros: Honest, Trustworthy, Professional

Cons: none

04/23/2008 Posted by chipnyc

Some of the reviews here struck me as odd. I mean, how can people be so gushing about a doctor's office? Having been through the procedure, I understand. Bonanni and his staff are uniformly professional, friendly -- no, genuinely warm --, and exactly what you wish you got in terms of service and professionalism in the rest of your life. Bonanni's surgical credentials are unsurpassed, and admittedly that is most important. But I can't underestimate the personalities and literally perfect customer service experience. Gotham Lasik is simply perfect.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful

04/13/2008 Posted by andrewstein

I had my lasik eye surgery done by Dr. Bonnani/Gotham Lasik last month and now have 20/15 vision! I just can't believe how amazing my eyesight is and my wife is amazed when I can read the highway signs as well as our 8 yr. old son & 5 yr. old daughter. Dr. Bonnani informed me of the choice of having both eyes done for distance(which is the option I choose) or doing 1 eye for distance and 1 eye for close up reading. Dr. Bonnani also informed me that your reading vision changes as you get older and it is easier to buy a $10 pair of reading glasses then to come back in for laser eye surgery adjustments in the future. I just read the previous person who posted claims that Dr. Bonnani never mentioned any of this to him? That was the first thing Dr. Bonnani explained in my initial free consultation so I find it a little hard to believe that he would just completely forget to mention the main choice that has to be made in any laser eye surgery. This guy can't be a real patient of Gotham Lasik when he says don't go to Dr. Bonnani because he is gay and made dinner plans with his boyfriend during the surgery. The whole surgery lasts about 5 minutes and Dr. Bonnani is looking through some super high tech periscope thing the whole time! And if someone is gay or not shouldn't affect their ability to be a good doctor. I have no idea if Dr. Bonnani is gay or not but that is not the criteria I used on selecting a qualified surgeon for something as important as my vision. I am sure there are a lot of gay people living/working in NYC, but I never try to pick out who is gay and who's not when my wife and I go shopping in NYC or to dinner or a broadway show. I have no idea about the prices being charged because I based my decision on a woman who my wife works with who went to Dr. Bonnani for her lasik eye surgery last year and swears by him so I don't know if he costs more or less than other lasik doctors. But I definitely would recommend Dr. Bonnani for lasik eye surgery to anyone.

Pros: 20/15 vision! Friendly and courteous staff. Beautiful office. Great cafe latte!

Cons: None

0 out of 2 people found this review helpful

04/11/2008 Posted by michaelsp

I had my Lasik surgery performed by Dr Brian Bonanni at Gotham Lasik several months ago. My biggest mistake! Before the surgery I had no problem reading the newspaper; now I need glasses everytime I want to read something. This was never explained to me properly beforehand. Very pushy salespeople. They just want to book you for surgery. Very desperate looking set-up. I was ready to walk out. But they kept hagling with me. I ended up paying $2K for the surgery. I should have stayed with my glasses instead. During my procedure, while working on my eyes, Dr Bonanni was making dinner plans with his boyfriend!! Yes, with his gay boyfriend; which I found very distasteful and unprofessional. In retrospect, I now realize how desperate they are at Gotham for patients. I should have stayed at TLC. It costs more (almost double of what I paid at Gotham), but the staff at TLC were so much more professional. I would stay away from Gotham Lasik and Dr Bonanni. Don't make the mistake that I committed!!

Pros: None

Cons: Pushy, Not professional

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful

03/21/2008 Posted by BlueWisdom

I got my lasik procedure done a week ago and things are GREAT. They take the time to make sure you understand exactly what you are getting into. I must have asked a million questions and all of the staff was friendly, patient and kind. Dr. Bonanni is awesome! I throughly checked him out, he has absolutely NO blemishes on his record and I "see" why. He knows a lot about the technology and has the most up to date equipment. He even gives patients his cell number to call him at any time. That's dedication. Now I have 20/15 vision and I'm loving it. No more glasses or contacts. If you are thinking about lasik, call them for a consultation. They will even work with you on financing the procedure - which is what I did.

Pros: The results (most important), service, and knowledge

Cons: None really. The saleswoman is aggressive but just go into it knowing what you want.

02/13/2008 Posted by MarkStevens84101

Being a Medical Student at Columbia University I often thought about getting rid of my glasses and get rid of my eyeglasses which would greatly benefit me in my research and medical career. After very careful consideration and homework I was referred to Gotham Lasik. Dr Brian Bonanni was absolutely amazing and he really took the time to explain what the procedure was all about and I was given the best medical care one can hope for. I had my surgery yesterday and I just couldn't wait to tell everyone how amazing my experience was. After less than 24 hours I can see 20/15 and there's nothing better than not having to wear glasses and be able to see whats around me. I highly recommend Dr. Bonanni, his expertise and caring staff.

Pros: Dr. Brian Bonanni

Cons: No Longer having to wear glasses!

02/08/2008 Posted by tuanatnyc

Two of my friends went to Dr. Bonnani 3 years ago. So I tried them out at their new office at Gotham Lasik. They certainly have the latest equipement and technology. Dr. Bonnani and the optician assistance were competent. What really turned me off were the aggressive sales folks. I don't mind hearing "Dr. Bonnani is the best". What bothered me was the persistance bad-mouthing of using any other doctor. Mentioning you are looking at an out-of-state doctor, they were the epitome of arrogance with ignorance. Anyways, I saw the other doctor outside of NYC was highly recommended. He had the same latest equipment as Dr Bonnani; 90%+ 20/20 or better plus a similar 20/20 or better guarantee. Very nice people, honest, and no pressure. The small office offers only Allegretto Wave and Interlase, and does not charge more for Interlase. The total cost was almost $2000 less then Dr. Bonnani. The doctor was listed with the company that sell the Allegretto Wave. Dr. Bonnani was not. But that may be just a delay. This is NOT an issue of money. But it does need to be justified. Anyways, the aggressive Sales folks from Gotham Lasik called me back. I explained that I decided to use the other doctor. Clearly, the Sales person was not happy, and did her same aggressive speal. Then she had her assistant to talk to me because he was from the my home state. I explained the same thing to him. And using the same aggressive tactics basically said anyone outside of NY very bad choice, and said "go ahead and do your surgery and we'll be here when you need your eyes fixed, <abrupt hang-up>". Wow. No-one should be pressure into surgery or a doctor. it is your eyes and your decision. Dr. Bonnani may be good. Gotham Lasik should not have to bad-mouth other doctors if you are good. I would rather patron equivalent doctors and staff who treat people with better respect.

Pros: Dr Bonnani and the optician where competent and nice

Cons: Aggressive high-pressure Sales, put down other doctors, and abruptly hang-up while telling you your eyes will be damaged

01/25/2008 Posted by joneke

From the moment I stepped foot in the Gotham Lasik office I felt comfortable. I am probably more afraid of eye doctors/procedures than anyone on the planet. I'm the person that would have to take 3 valium just for a regular eye check up. Dr. Bonanni and his assistant Kali are extremely kind, patient and knowlegable. I was shocked at how quick and painless the procedure is and I now have 20/15 vision. During my first visit I watched a video explaining exactly how everything works and then sat down with Dr. Bonanni who took his time with me. Not the usual rushed doctor visit that leaves you feeling frustrated and anxious. The equipment is state of the art and the office has a calm energy. I scheduled my op after my first visit so the next time I was in the office was for the procedure. I was in the office a total of 1 hour and 15 minutes. Following that there is very little that has to be done.....resting your eyes the remainder of that day and then drops 4 times a day for a week. THATS IT!!!! well, along with follow up visits but thats just to be sure you are healing properly. Not going to lie...its costly but when I thought of how much it costs to get a yearly eye exam and new glasses/lenses it pays for itself in no time and in the long run I'm going to save money. So I bought a pair of Prada sunglasses from them to protect my investment! They share an office with Gotham Aesthetics. I was so impressed with the office as a whole that I now see Claudio on the aesthetic side for facials. Can't speak highly enough of the entire group and their professionalism. Last but not least....their new year's eve bash is ROCKIN! so be sure you get on the guest list! Another satisfied customer! Thanks guys! Kelly

01/22/2008 Posted by superk8nyc

So for the past few months I did tremendous research on Lasik surgeons in NYC. Gotham Lasik had the best reveiws both online and from people I talked to. When I went for my consultation they were friendly, knowledgeable, and patient (with my hundreds of questions). At the consultation Dr. Bonanni himself came to talk with me about my eyes, my procedure, and to answer more of my questions. I went back a month later and had extrememly successful Lasik. My vision is now 2015! That's better than I ever had with my glasses or contacts. Gotham Lasik has all of the newest technologies and Dr. Bonanni is extremely talented and wonderful. I HIGHLY recommend Gotham Lasik and Dr. Bonanni to anyone who asks.

Pros: Dr. Bonanni, staff, care, procedure, knowledge

Cons: none

01/15/2008 Posted by aether25

I went for a consultation at a friend's recommendation. His procedure was successful and I had been looking for an office in which I felt comfortable and could trust. This was it. The staff is enormously professional, informative and friendly. The office clean, comfortable and holds the most modern technology available. That afternoon, I spoke with several at Gotham Lasik about what they recommended and what I could expect. I spent time with Dr. Bonanni, who answered my questions and provided additional insight into Intralase and vision correction. I booked the procedure that day for two weeks later. The procedure went off without a hitch. I was made comfortable during my time with the doctor, constantly informed as to what would happen and how things would proceed. It was brief, painless, bladefree and exactly what I expected. It now approaches 3 months after the procedure and I couldn't be happier! My eyes feel comfortable and my vision is better then perfect. I have scheduled and kept appointments with Dr. Bonanni as check-ups, all of which have been brief and extremely positive experiences. Dr. Bonanni and his staff are the best one might find. A wonderful experience that I would recommend to anyone without hesitation; it changes your life.

Pros: Great doctor, amazing staff, comfortable, modern space