(212) 581-1818

251 W 50th St
New York, NY 10019 40.7619 -73.985

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Theater District - Times Square, Midtown

Reviews & Ratings for Toloache

4 Star Rating: Recommended

47 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
2 Star Rating: Below Average

11/06/09

Rip Off

by bigbeergut

This place is an absolute rip off. The food is just okay, which is a lot better than most Mexican in NYC I will admit. But the prices are absurd. They charge four bucks for chips and salsa. I would boycott on that basis alone. Stay away!

  • Pros: Food is okay which is saying a lot for NYC Mexican food
  • Cons: Price, portion size
4 Star Rating: Recommended

09/18/09

Not Americanized Mexican

by bchbumnyc

A lively place with a friendly staff and a great atmosphere. No complaints about the food only the size of the servings. Don't be so stingy!

  • Pros: great food
  • Cons: small portions
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/25/09

Brilliant Margaritas, great food

by Mellorstein

We were touched by the very warm, friendly service. The food is great (try the spicy red guacamole) and the frozen Margaritas are the best in town. This is our new favorite in the Theater District.

  • Pros: Delicious food, charming service
  • Cons: Can be crowded at cocktail hour
4 Star Rating: Recommended

05/24/09

Great in Theaterland

by Wingate

At last, a good, cheerful restaurant/bar in the Theater District. Good, imaginative food and charming service. First-rate margaritas, good Mexican beer and a reasonable wine list (though wine isn't really ideal with Mexican food).

Highly recommended.

  • Pros: Excellent, Imaginate Food, Pleasant Service
  • Cons: Noisy, Can be Crowded
4 Star Rating: Recommended

05/02/09

Still dreaming about that Guacamole

by girlsgottaeat

The trio of guacamole is unbelievable!! Pomegranate in your guacamole???!! who would have thought!! I couldn't get enough of it. The blueberry margarita was delicioso! It was so rich, packed with antioxidants you didn't feel guilty about having it at all!! Definitely a do over!

  • Pros: Drinks, Guacamole
  • Cons: small, pricey
4 Star Rating: Recommended

04/29/09

great margaritas!

by robpsheehan

went last yr, great time...

the tequila selection was excellent.

got in right away, good service.

very accessible, in midtown.

am i at 100 chars yet? sheesh...

1 Star Rating: Poor

04/22/09

Testing again

by princess1978

I need to test this website to see how it works, please don't worry about my review, testing testing testing

  • Pros: test
  • Cons: test2
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/07/09

Create your own fun

by urbanmuse

Love this place! It's cozy & fun and not TOO loud and right in the Theater District. The Margarita menu will get you right into the spirit with an interesting selection you'll want to try. Same goes for the custom made guacamole, a must. But for a non-meat eating person like me, there were plenty of choices and everything tasted clean and fresh- not drenched in sauce and beans. The Lobster Tacos were amazing. A great place for a small meal or an evening. Two thumbs up from me.

  • Pros: fresh food, innovative selections, good for small tasting or full meal
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/02/09

Times Square Gem That will impress NYC Foodies

by karnyc

This is the place I can take family and friends to and know they will be duely impressed! Lobster tacos, guacamole made to order(including a unique "fruit" guacamole that is lovely), tasty sangria, and the creamiest flan I've ever had! The service is friendly and knowledgeable, and the decor is fantastic.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/25/09

Fantastic Mexican Food

by vitalyp

Had their lunch special and it was great. Can't wait to go back to NY. Check out the happy hour specials too.

  • Pros: Example: best croissants in town
  • Cons: What are the drawbacks?

Showing 1-10 of 45 reviews

Lists In Manhattan

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Toloache

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Ottimo

6 W 24th St, New York, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cantina Latina

243 E 14th St , New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Nook Restaurant

746 9th Ave, New York, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cantina Latina

243 E 14th St , New York, NY

Advertisement