Settebello

(212) 777-3355

647 E 11th St
New York, NY 10009 40.7269 -73.9777

Neighborhoods: Alphabet City, Downtown, East Village

Reviews & Ratings for Settebello

4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

14 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review

Showing 1-10 of 14 reviews

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by Bridgetann

May 20, 2009

My friend and I decided to give Matilda a try based on a recommendation.

We had the absolute best time! Our waiter was so funny and entertaining I started crying I was laughing so hard! The table next to us was celebrating an anniversary and chef made a cake and shared it with the whole restaurant.

We were also presently surprised it was ladies night and we got to drink for free. That's right ladies get half off mixed drinks and unlimited free wine every Tuesday. Yes, ladies all you can drink for free!

The menu is an interesting Mexican Italian fusion and both our meals were very good.

If you are looking to put your worries behind you and enjoy yourself in a great atmosphere I definitely recommend checking out Matildas! It is so cute!

  • Pros: Waitstaff, atmosphere, Waitstaff drinks, and yeah food

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by gregorie

January 16, 2009

The other night, had an awesome meal at matilda

food was great, celery soup and meat tacos was fantasic

plus the sangria is brillent

  • Pros: amazing food
  • Cons: cant stay there all night and eat it all

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by NYC1223

December 21, 2008

Food is great (definitely different) and so is the service. Owners always make us feel like we are at home.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by Bucaiolicelepaste

September 24, 2008

I don't know what this Susan is talking about! She is completely out of her mind!!! Every time i go to Matilda i have a great experience. Service exist and it is the best service i ever had in restaurants, casual, fun and professional at the same time. About the food, i always have fresh ingredients, i like everything on the menu, their special drinks and sangria are amazing. Nobody at 7.30 p.m.? Maybe because this place get crowded after 8.30...I don't think they will be out of business soon, actually since sometimes it's even hard to get a table, i think they will last for a long time! Miss " Susan in the box", i think your problem was another, maybe a bad hair day? Or should i say a bad breath day?? You better go back to your box!

  • Pros: Great Prosejitos, tacos and great deal for Brunch!
  • Cons: None

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 1 No

1 Star Rating: Poor

by susanobx

September 11, 2008

Whatever this place may once have been, the end is near. Completely empty at 7:30 PM -- and now I know why. Service as non-existent, even though we were the only people in the place. A pitcher of Sangria arrived at our table so frozen, it was not drinkable. The food in several of the dishes we were served had clearly gone bad... a pervasive garbage-like odor wafted off the calmari. Salads were missing half of their listed ingredients. Two in our party got sick after the meal, possibly from one of the vegetarian dishes. The restaurant is now cash only. I think they will be out of business by the time you read this. If not, use extreme caution when contemplating an evening at this place.

  • Pros: Absolutely empty so no problems getting seated
  • Cons: Everything else

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by grigagyal

August 11, 2008

I recently went to Matilda with a group of 5 friends. The chef offered to create a unique "tasting" for us and brought course after course of amazing food based on our preferences. I loved the nopalos and fish sausages. The chocolate jalapeno gelato at the end put us over the top. Everyone loved the inventive food and the great atmosphere. We sat and ate in a relaxed and festive spirit for hours. Matilda is now my favorite restaurant in New York for a special night out.

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

4 Star Rating: Recommended

by eatsny

August 04, 2008

great find on les. great drinks. the prosejito is refreshing and delicious. good for a date or group. nice blend of italian and mexican cuisines. will go back.

  • Pros: great drinks

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

by MM8729

February 11, 2008

I have been here a couple times and I feel like I am coming home every time. The owners are kind, outgoing, and very attentive. The tacos alla fiorentina are like nothing else I've ever tasted, I can't get enough of the guacamole and the tropical pico de gallo, and every time I try something new I'm happy! The husband and wife are each fluent in English and each other's languages and their daughter is adorable. Don't be afraid to ask for changes in your meal (if you like it less spicy or more spicy), they are more than willing to accommodate. Everything is fresh and light, you'll be well-fed but never feel too full. They really know food. Thank you, Matilda!

  • Pros: atmosphere, cheery decor, amazing food, more-than-reasonable prices
  • Cons: none!

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

4 Star Rating: Recommended

by DinerFromTO

January 25, 2008

I choose this restaurant by googling and then reading reviews for ones that appealed to me. I have to say that my boyfriend and I were very pleased with the choice. The food was very creative and interesting. I especially liked the nachos...they are not like any anyone has ever had because the ingredients (like corn and a drizzle of truffle oil) are so unusual, but they worked like crazy. Took the advice of other reviewers and had their signature cocktail, the Prosecito (mojito made with Prosecco - sparkling wine). This was so light and refreshing that I will definitely be copying it for my summer beverage by the pool!!! The whole fish my boyfriend ordered was so fresh, moist and flavourful. The filet mignon tacos needed a bit of zing but were still quite palatable. Service was very friendly and definitely not obtrusive. I met the owner and she was very lovely. All in all, a wonderful find that I will definitely go back to.

  • Pros: Food, cocktails, and a knockout bathroom
  • Cons: Long wait for drinks

Write comment on this review

Was this review helpful?

0 Yes / 0 No

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Contributor

January 25, 2008

This restaurant has the best Mexican food that I have ever tasted. The food is well seasoned with the right spices and herbs. This place has great customers service. Just come and enjoy dinner or lunch with family and friends

Write comment on this review

Advertisement

Things To Do Nearby Settebello

brought to you by Visa

Settebello

647 E 11th St
New York, NY 10009

Lists In Manhattan

Best of Citysearch

Best Nightlife

New York

Cheap haircuts. Beefy hamburgers. Sexy bartenders! Discover the best finds in the city.

view more polls & winners

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Ginza Japanese Restaurant

800 Lexington Ave, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

E J's Luncheonette

447 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Havana Alma de Cuba

94 Christopher St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Fig & Olive

10 E 52nd St, New York, NY

Advertisement