Pete's Tavern

07/11/2008 Posted by elledriver2008

My friend and I went there after work for drinks outside and some appetizers. Drinks were fine, service was slow and at best unorganized. I ordered fried calamari, very basic. The order came out half cooked the batter was doughy and raw, COMPLETELY tasteless. I sampled a few disgusting bites and waited almost a half an hour before our waiter came back to our table so that I could express my dissatifaction. I showed him how undercooked this order was and he agreed. He took back the calamari and returned about 10 minutes later with the EXACT SAME PLATE OF CALAMARI!!! THEY TOOK THE PLATE OF FOOD THAT WE TOUCHED AND ATE OFF OF AND PLACED IT DIRECTLY BACK INTO THE FRYER. THE WAITER CAME BACK WITH THE EXACT SAME PLATE OF FOOD BUT NOW MORE CRISPY AND COOKED! I was expecting them to actually bring us what we ordered but cooked this time. We assumed they would prepare this appetizer properly the second time around, instead of RECYCLING OUR FOOD! I do know that this is an unsafe way to handle food. If this is a common practice at Pete's Tavern, then contaminated food is a given. I was flabbergasted! I would strongly recommend NOT eating anything out of the fryer, nor the entire menu.

Pros: OUTDOOR SEATING - BUT GRIMEY AS HELL

Cons: RUDE SERVICE, UNDERCOOKED FOOD, UNCLEAN, OVERPRICED.

06/12/2008 Posted by nshurigina

I left the restaurant I work at in search of outside seating, a good beer and burger....My GM reminded me about Pete's Tavern...I've been to Pete's before and enjoyed myself....so I was pretty excited to go and get some good food, relax after a day at work at my own restaurant...unfortunately, it didn't quite happen as I had imagined...I was greeted and ceremoniously dismissed by the male host who said "we don't seat parties of 1 outside"...look I can understand maybe having a policy of not allowing guests to sit outside just for drinks after a certain hour but to not allow someone who was interested in sitting down to have dinner just because they are by themselves is a bit ridiculous...therefore I will no longer be coming to this establishment...So, be forewarned, if you are interested in just chilling out by yourself skip Pete's Tavern.

Pros: location

Cons: not very service oriented or friendly

05/16/2008 Posted by itdoesnttakemuch

The Bartender was very nice and helped us as soon as we came in. Our waitress didn't seem to care whether or not we received good service. In fact, she made us feel as if we were a nuisance when we ordered our food. This led us to believe she must be in some way related to the owner. We gave her the benefit of the doubt after our first encounter. But when she messed up several items in our order, we asked for her to fix the problem. She then seemed really irritated. The wings were enjoyable, but nothing spectacular. The burgers were ppppoison.

Pros: great history, wonderful location, nice bartender

Cons: waitress made darth vader seem friendly

02/06/2008 Posted by arib

Good bar food. Highly recommend the house Ale. It gets a bit too crowded and uncomfortable, but if you can grab a booth with some friends you'll be pleased. I will say that I have NO idea why this place is ranked as having some of the best wings in NYC. They're quite average. Sure they were ok honey bbq wings, but certainly not much better than you would expect to get from KFC.

Pros: Pete's Ale, A good place to drink with friends

Cons: Nothing fancy here.

10/27/2007 Posted by nyclawyer09

I was taking a stroll around the area with my lady. I wanted sushi BUT she wanted Pete's Tavern. The service was great. The waiter recommended a delicious beer which I enjoyed with a monster burger. Although it seems like a normal bar for some odd reason it was a little more.

Pros: great staff and great burgers

Cons: none

03/06/2007 Posted by davemoore

Stopped by early Saturday evening because of its history. Found comfortable neighborhood bar, $5.50 for mug of Stella, $12 for burger; pleasant crowd. OK but nothing special. So now I have been to oldest bar in NYC. You will have more fun at McSorley.

01/15/2007 Posted by n1y1c1

Went there for appetizers and drinks on a Wed. night, pretty crowded & loud in bar area. We were seated in back end of restaurant in a booth - by far one of the most uncomfortable seats ever. Back end was more low-key for conversation. Got the spring rolls and grilled calamari - spring rolls had sundried tomatoes in them which is jsut weird and they weren't good at all, small portion also. The grilled calamari tasted as if it was left under the heat lamps for an hour, dried and extremely chewy. Overall, maybe didn't get the right things on the menu, so might give it another shot - although the atomsphere has an dive-bar feel, so I don't see myself ordering anything more then a sandwich with fries at a place like this. Oh, and the waitress brought us corona's when we asked for peroni's....

Pros: Better Bar Scene then restaurant

11/12/2006 Posted by mickie227

I have been to Pete's just a few times and had an "OK" experience. I decided to try it again because I was dogsitting down the street and was too lazy to research a new spot in the 'hood. What a mistake. My friend and I took a booth by the bar. It was loud and crowded. Not a problem, I expected that. The server was no where to be found (which I read in other reviews but brushed it off as a bad experience). When we finally did get our food, the server screwed up our order, TWICE!!! The salmon I ordered was almost chewy, how is that possible!?!??! It took the server 30 minutes to bring me my bill! WTF?? I have many other complaints about that night but I choose to block them out and move on. PETE'S TAVERN IS NOT WORTH IT!!!!!! If I wasn't in such a hurry to enjoy evening with my friend I would have complained to the manager. I hate to say it but this place "is not good" for a meal.

Pros: ???

Cons: pretty much everything

11/08/2006 Posted by celticait

Not the greatest food in the world, but the menu is really diverse- you're bound to find something you like! The really cool atmosphere makes up for it a thousand times over. I really enjoy this place!

09/12/2006 Posted by patriots81

I go back here again and again. The food is consistently good, and not at all expensive. The atmosphere is comfortable and inviting. I love the old school look and feel. A NYC staple.