Reviews & Ratings for Paddy McGuire's

06/01/11

an ACTUAL Irish Pub

by Beer Enthusiast

the title of this review speaks for itself. you've got to love a pub that actually has some Ireland behind it

02/06/07

A neighborhood pub rich in trademark Irish touches.

by Contributor

The Scene
Decorated with an astonishing number of white and green mini-Christmas tree lights and genuine Irish doors, Paddy McGuire's is a theme park for Irish drinking. While primarily a neighborhood pub, Paddy's attracts large numbers of students and fans of Emerald Isle kitsch.

The Draw
The staff hail from all over England, Ireland and Hell's Kitchen. Pints are imperial (20 ounces), the TVs above the bar are always turned to a sports program. There's also a pool table and darts. As with any Irish bar worth its green poster-board shamrock cutouts, Paddy's has Guinness on tap, but it rounds out the selection with 15 beers from places as exotic as the Czech Republic and Golden, Colorado.

02/09/05

A+++++

by lucyr

Nice, cozy, friendly place. Good bartenders. Owner is handsome, witty & charming!

11/13/02

Texas friendly

by lovenyc

Paddy's isn't fancy, but a great place to hang with friends! The place is friendly and down to earth. Shawn and Phil are awesome bartenders and always have something to say. Met a great guy from Kentucky and kick myself for not forwarding my #s to him. The people that frequent the place are true to the core. That is great to find in NYC. I always have a great time at Paddy's.

• Pros: Bartenders, Pool Tables

10/23/02

yes!

by johnsokr

i love this place. the music leaves something to be desired, but my buddies and i frequent this place after work. 2 decent pool tables, golden tee, and all the bud my heart desires. bartenders are friendly, and understand the phrase "buy-back". highly recommend it.

07/07/02

*********

by mikemcguire

Good, solid New York/Irish neighborhood bar. Two pool tables so the wait for a game is never very long. Fast, friendly, knowledgable staff, led by a charming owner.

• Pros: Good beer selection, Two pool tables, Friendly staff
• Cons: No food

07/06/02

Cozy little joint...

by ruck1977

Nice music, nice atmosphere...very relaxing. About 12 different beers on tap, but we paid $12 bucks for a Sam Adams Draft and a Raspberry Stoli' and Sprite...you be the judge.

Nice place to sit and talk, as well as have a good time.

• Pros: Small, music
• Cons: expensive