(212) 977-7600

858 9TH Ave Ste 1
New York, NY 10019 40.7669 -73.9863

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Midtown, Clinton

Reviews & Ratings for Route 66 Cafe Inc

3.5 Star Rating: Average

6 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
1 Star Rating: Poor

04/05/09

Bad service outweighs good food

by Jenniela

We have had three experiences with Route 66, two eat-in and one delivery. the First Eat-in was terrible. The service was lousy and the food was not memorable. The Second eat-in Experience was very pleasant. the food was great as was the service and our final experience came today. We ordered take-out brunch through their website. Forty- Five minutes later I called to check on our order and the person who answered the phone assured me my order was on the way. I called fifteen minutes later when the food still hadn't arrived (now waiting an hour) and the woman who answered the phone told me that the website is not in service and not controlled by them; that the person who answered the phone didn't even work at the restaurant and they never got my order. So to sum up, and hour after ordering we have no food, a person telling us our food is on the way who doesn't even work there and a employee who while mildly apologetic about the bogus website and false assurances of delivery by a random person answering phone, doesn't care to do anything about it! They have lost our business and I will make sure to let everyone know about my terrible experiences!

  • Pros: good food
  • Cons: terrible service, never received delivery order
3 Star Rating: Average

06/14/08

Terrible Service, but decent food

by kdub25

I went here tonight with my girlfriend. They sat us right away and gave us water and the menus, but then they waited about 10 minutes or so before asking us even for drinks. So then when we give our drink orders, somebody else comes by to take our orders, not knowing that we had already just given our drink orders to somebody else. To be honest, I don't know who our waitress was, because there were two women taking our orders. Also, I don't know if there was a host/hostess or who that was, and I don't think there was a manager on duty.

So after they came back and took our food orders, my girlfriend ordered the Penne Ala Vodka and I ordered the Sirloin Steak. On the menu it says that it is served with soup, but they never asked me what soup I wanted, nor did they bring any. I wasn't really in the mood for soup, but I felt a little odd that they didn't offer it to me, or even the option of a salad or something else. At this point also, every other table had bread on it, but not ours. They never brought us bread the entire time.

Our food came out quickly, but that's on the kitchen staff. The food was overall pretty good, but I couldn't help but feel like I was eating an Applebee's steak. For a sirloin there was a lot of fat on the steak, but all in all it was rather tasty. I would actually reccommend the food just on taste alone, and it's fairly reasonably priced. But during the entire time we were eating, they did not come over once to ask us how our meal was, or whether we needed anything. Only an awkward 'do you need anything else' right when they brought the food. Nobody ever came to refill our waters even though there was none in my glass. I finished my wine and they didn't ask if I wanted another glass (I didn't, but still). I would have asked for more water if somebody had actually come. By the time we finished, we were so fed up with the service we didn't even consider dessert. I left a small tip because I was so appalled at the service. Not going back...

  • Pros: Tasty, not cheap, but reasonably priced
  • Cons: Awful service, no atmosphere
4 Star Rating: Recommended

12/29/06

Delivery Route To My Tummy

by b00pi3flak3s

Portion control and cheap prices make this a little gem in the west side till you experience their whack customer service. Dining in is weird, but delivery is much better.

  • Pros: Food, Prices, Delivery
  • Cons: Service (at times), Small Cafe
4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

02/10/03

Huge menu

by Gradle

The place was great. The menu was huge and so were the portions. This would be an excelllent spot for lunch. Sandwiches with a nice original touch. Wonderful selction of fresh fish too!

  • Pros: Greta lunch menu, Good specials
  • Cons: Nothing fancy
3.5 Star Rating: Average

05/30/02

Fantastic Find

by alsmez

In an area packed with little hole-in-the-wall burger joints, Route 66 is a standout. The prices are reasonable, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the food is great. Their chicken cobb salad is the best I've had anywhere...a far cry from the usual bowl of iceberg lettuce. Portions are large and prices are small....what could be better? Drawback: sometimes the service is s-l-o-w.

  • Pros: Salads, roomy seating
  • Cons: Slow service

Lists In Manhattan

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Route 66 Cafe Inc

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

3 Star Rating: Average

BLVD

199 Bowery, New York, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Crooked Tree

110 Saint Marks Place, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Tom's Restaurant

2880 Broadway, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

AYZA Wine & Chocolate Bar

11 W 31st St, New York, NY

Advertisement